The company’s name is pretty self explanatory, MFCO manufactures radio frequency (RF) filters and related components for eliminating interference and facilitating signal processing for the following markets: Cable Television, Broadcast, Commercial and Military Communications, Avionics, Radar, Navigation and Defense. The 10-K offers as much information as you would expect from a ~$1.2mm market cap company that is attempting to go dark (more on that later). The radio frequency market, from what I can tell, is very competitive. It seems like there are a number of Mom and Pop type manufacturers and one large competitor of note is owned by Dover Corporation (DOV). Long story short, the company doesn’t benefit from a huge moat, but from what I can tell they have built up a solid reputation of being able to deliver custom applications to customers quickly. When you search for the term ‘Competition’ in the 10-K, the following is the only result,
“The principal competitive factors facing both MFC are price, technical performance, service and the ability to produce in quantity to specific delivery schedules. Based on these factors, the Company believes it competes favorably in its markets.”
To be able to produce in such quantity and customization you would need a state of the art facility one would think? Talk about burying the lead, now we are to the whole point of the article. The company owns its 40,000 square foot office and manufacturing facility in East Syracuse, NY and the 3.7 acre lot it sits on. Based on precedent transactions in East Syracuse it seems $75-100/sqft is close to fair value. That’s at least $3mm for the value of the building compared to $1.2mm market cap. Let’s jump into quick approximation of what liquidation value would be.
Liquidation Value Estimate (values as of 6/30/19)
Net Working Capital: $1,097,856
- Given the company’s backlog of ~$740k, I didn’t make any adjustment to inventory.
Long Term Liability: $(179,178)
- This is actually a mortgage against the property with KeyBank. From what I could gather I think proceeds were used for working capital and to shore up the balance sheet after a special dividend in 2012/2013. Original principal was $500,000, taken out in July 2013 with a 10-year term.
- $3,500,000 for the value of the 40,000 square feet of manufacturing and office space. This assumes a price of $87.50/sqft, approximately what a light industrial building sold for in September of 2019.
- $259,200 of Land. MFCO is not utilizing all of the 3.7 acres, only about 1 acre at the stated square footage. I’m assigning what I think is a very conservative estimate of $96,000/acre. Why $96k? There was a half acre lot that sold for double that amount per acre in June in East Syracuse.
- $1,166,141 for Machinery & Equipment. The estimate is 1/3 of what is listed in the 10-K, again to be conservative. As stated above, the facility needs to be state of the art to compete and deliver in the quantity and speed necessary for customers. From the December 2018 10-K:
“Efficient computer simulation, design and analysis software enhanced by proprietary MFC developed software, allow rapid and accurate filter development at reasonable cost…Other in-house testing facilities include environmental chambers capable of testing products for temperatures of -40 to 200 degrees Celsius and humidity up to 100 percent. Several high power amplifiers are available for power tests. We have 2500 watt capability from 88-108Mhz with 200 watt capability up to 2200 Mhz. Facilities are also available for salt spray, sand and dust, shock and vibration, RFI leakage and altitude testing.”
- Total Liquidation Value Estimate = $5,844,019
- Shares outstanding (as of 8/1/19) = 2,579,238
- Liquidation Value per Share = $2.26
- Closing price as of 11/18/19 = $0.51
- Potential return = 443%
I know I know, there are many reasons to shoot this down. I will try to answer some of them below and you can ask any I miss in the comments.
Isn’t the business just a melting ice cube?
Not exactly. While the business is volatile, they jump back and forth between positive EBITDA and should do between $0.2-0.3mm of EBITDA in Fiscal 2019 which ended 9/30/19. The biggest risk I see is their reliance on a couple large customers. Two customers usually take up 30-50% of total revenue. This explains the volatility as different capital spending programs are undertaken. The business, while not great, could be a lot worse.
So the company is going dark?
Well trying to, in May they filed an 8-K with the following:
“On May 2, 2019, the Board of Directors of Microwave Filter Company, Inc. (“MFCO” or the “Company”) unanimously approved the filing of Form 15 which is a voluntary filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission, also known as the Certification and Notice of Termination of Registration.
The Company’s Board of Directors considered the costs
associated with the preparation and filing of reports, management time spent on
the documents and the costs of outside legal and accounting resources. The Company will continue to put their
financial statements on its
15 days later they filed a 15-12G showing they have 459 holders of record, quite a ways from the less than 299 needed to go dark. The company has been buying back shares over the last few years, a couple hundred of dollars at a time, so my guess is they have been trying to work this down. I don’t see going dark as a negative really, as long as they are still making financials available to us. The part that would worry me about them going dark is the next piece.
Insiders Own Very Little
Now this isn’t always bad but combined with going Dark, it’s harder to feel like management has your back if they don’t have a material investment in the company. The 10 person Director and Executive Officer group as a whole own 6.9% of the company. Normally that would be an average amount but given the market cap is $1.2mm, 6.9% is very little compared to any members net worth, I’m guessing at least.
Other Investors Involved
Zeff Capital had offered to purchase the company in January of 2018 for $0.72/share. At the time he had owned 8.6% of outstanding shares. In the original letter he references the company’s willingness to go Dark. Zeff withdrew the offer in June of 2018. He also sold down his stake below 5% recently in 2019 so he no longer has to disclose his holdings.
I think I’ve laid out how unique of a situation this is at MFCO with the company currently trading for less than 25% of my estimate of liquidation value. At the very least the stock should reflect the value of the office building they own and the net working capital which would give us a even more conservative liquidation value of $1.71/share, 335% greater than the close on 11/18/19.
5 thoughts on “Microwave Filter Company (MFCO): Trading at 25% of Liquidation Value”
Awesome idea! Have you spoken to management? I agree the biggest red flag is lack of insider ownership, although thier salaries are modest.
I haven’t spoken to management yet. I might try to reach out sometime in the next month.
Interesting. So the premise seems to be that management’s 7m acc.depreciation on the PP&E is unfounded because the value of the land underneath them and their building has actually appreciated. That’s why you’ve manually had to estimate the depreciative impact on machinery and equipment? Is there a reason why management can’t adjust its 7m figure if its clear the building/land were not depreciating, but actually appreciating? Thanks!
On the machinery and equipment I’m just taking a % of stated cost, you make a good point that they are already depreciating this but I’m assuming there is some value that should be assigned to this in a liquidation or sale scenario.
I’d say the premise is that based on comps in the vicinity of the company’s headquarters in East Syracuse, NY; the value of the building, land, and net working capital is much greater than today’s share price.
edit to the first paragraph…..in a liquidation or sale scenario that is greater than the PP&E stated on the balance sheet.